Skip Navigation LinksBlog

Negative vitamin articles! Fact or Fiction?

Question: from Larry

This month two different magazines (Prevention and Reader's Digest) published articles saying that researchers are now questioning the effectiveness of multi-vitamins specifically disclaiming previous studies of the assets of the anti-oxidants (A, C and E vitamins).

Both articles suggested there is little to no evidence that these vitamins are helping to guard against any disease or making you healthier. Both also warned of excessive quantities of vitamins in today's multi-vitamins.

Both also agreed that their recommendations to patients today are Fish Oil and Vitamin D as they do have known benefits and most people don't consume in adequate supply (or get enough sun to make up the difference). I was curious if you have any feelings on this.

Answer: from Warren

Over the years there have been many articles published in various journals suggesting that various vitamins are not effective. In some cases they are correct when taken in the context of the study itself. A good example is Vitamin E.

There was a study done some time ago in which the researchers reached a conclusion that not only was Vitamin E not beneficial for health but could potentially even be dangerous. This study got a lot of media attention but very few of the media picked up the obvious flaws in it…which were several. The first thing is that the form of Vitamin E used in the study was not a natural one but rather a synthetic and was of a narrow spectrum.

In order for Vitamin E to be effective it has to be natural and a broad spectrum...for example, not only include alpha tocopherols but also gamma. But, it doesn't stop there. Even for mixed tocopherols to be effective it has to be taken with tocotrienols.

Vitamin E is not present in nature as a single isolate molecule so the studies that gave a negative result were doomed to fail from the outset...something that some commentators believe was the researchers’ objective in the first place.

With regard to Vitamin A, there has been some concern that high levels of Vitamin A can be a negative for bones...but that is not really a concern as most responsible manufacturers provide the Vitamin A in the form of mixed carotenoids which overcomes that issue. The carotenoids convert in the body to Vitamin A, but only to the extent that it is needed.

There have also been negative studies on beta-carotene (which is a carotenoid) but this was of the synthetic type not the natural broad spectrum type such as we use. The efficacy is quite different. With regard to Vitamin C, I agree that it is possible to overdose with this vitamin and many people do. There are also many different forms of Vitamin C and when in ascorbic acid form large doses can act as a pro-oxidant which is exactly the opposite of what is desired.

I agree about fish oil in that most people do not take enough and that it is essential. In so far as Vitamin D is concerned, we do not believe that people should take large doses of this. It is not natural and can be damaging. The only effective and safe way to get it is through the sun.

Since the media has instilled fear in the minds of people about sunlight, cancer rates have increased and will continue to do so until people start sensibly embracing the sun. Sensible sun exposure protects against cancer. It doesn't promote it. The key with vitamins is to have them in modest amounts but use the correct form and ensure they are broad spectrum and comprehensive. They are all interdependent.

Comments  (1)

  • SRINI G
    April 22, 2010

    Warren

    Just an additional question on this. How far you think The Premium Total balance products ingredients are co-ordianting each other ? It is a basic question but still I hope because you are already on the 3rd version of this product hope you have achieved the good balance of vitamins and nutrients so that they don't contradict each other in your formulas. I would appreciate if you elaborate on this aspect.  By the way Me and mywife are in to our 3rd month of using your total balance products. I will posy my references at the end of  6months of usage.

    Thanks
    Srini

Leave a comment

  •    
     
     
     
     
       
  • Your privacy is important to us, please read our privacy statement .


  •  

Shop

Connect With Us
Customer Information
Company

All material provided within this website is for informational and educational purposes only, and is not to be construed as medical advice or instruction. No action should be taken solely on the contents of this website. Consult your physician or a qualified health professional on any matters regarding your health and wellbeing or on any opinions expressed within this website. The information provided in our newsletters and special reports is believed to be accurate based on the best judgment of the Company and the authors. However, the reader is responsible for consulting with their own health professional on any matters raised within. Neither the company nor the author/s of any information provided accept responsibility for the actions or consequential results of any action taken by any reader.

TRUSTe online privacy certification
McAfee Secure sites help keep you safe from identity theft, credit card fraud, spyware, spam, viruses and online scams

© 1999-2014 Xtend-Life . All rights reserved.